'Occupy' an activist meeting

 Resize text         Printer-friendly version of this article Printer-friendly version of this article

I go to a number of veterinary and livestock-related meetings throughout the year and it’s not uncommon for anti-animal agriculture activists to show up either as a paid attendee (some who come to listen and even attempt to dialogue or quietly “gather intel”), or as a flagrant protestor in a cow suit.  

It was refreshing to see our industry do the very same thing (minus the cow suit). Sarah Hubbart, communications director for the Animal Agriculture Alliance, recently wrote a report from one of the Alliance's staffers who attended the Conference to End Factory Farming in Arlington, Va. Hubbart’s intriguing report (read her re-cap here)  said the event was co-hosted by Farm Sanctuary and the ASPCA and sponsored by a wide variety of extremist organizations and companies including the Humane Society of the United States, Mercy for Animals, Compassion Over Killing, A Well Fed World, Compassion in World Farming, E: The Environmental Magazine, Discovery’s TreeHugger, and Whole Foods Market.

Hubbart said there were about 300 people in attendance, the bulk of which were middle-aged women. “Tehre were many of the same people who had attended other recent activist meetings in D.C.,” Hubbart told me.

Hubbart’s report said: Many speakers revealed just how out of step with American values they are during their presentations. For example, Holly Cheever, of HSUS’ Veterinary Medical Association Leadership Council said that “slaughterhouses are a kind of Auschwitz”. This equating of human suffering with agricultural practices not only diminishes the horrors inflicted upon the victims of the Holocaust, but is a sentiment commonly expressed by PETA and other extremist organizations.

Hubbart's colleague also collected a list of disturbing quotes from speakers at the meeting including:

  • “The lifeblood of Mercy For Animals is our undercover investigations of animal agriculture.” – Nathan Runkle (Mercy for Animals)
  • “In California, if a farmer came out in criticism of the ballot initiative, they would be subject to undercover investigation and sued.” – David Wolfson (Milbank Tweed)
  • “Meat consumption shouldn’t be normal.” – Gene Baur (Farm Sanctuary)

Hubbart said it was interesting that many of the speakers and attendees rejected the more mainstream approach of conference speaker Dr. John Ikerd of the University of Missouri, who supports pasture-based, small-scale animal agriculture. “Eliminating animal agriculture entirely is the preferred goal.”

Hubbart added that David Wolfson, who also spoke and is a lawyer and NYU professor, discussed the tactics used against farmers and ranchers during CA’s Prop 2 campaign. “It was pretty eye-opening. The tactic of obtaining ‘undercover’ photography and video was discussed by Nathan Runkle, director of Mercy for Animals. He said it is the ‘life blood’ of his organization, so producers must remain wary of these tactics.”

Activists are not shy about attending livestock events whether in a quiet manner or making a scene. We in the industry should also not be shy about attending their events like the Ag Alliance staffer did. That took some guts. “It is crucial that industry understand the true agenda of these extremist groups,” Hubbart said. “Conferences such as this one can be an important learning opportunity.”

If you don’t know about the Animal Agriculture Alliance, become familiar with them as they are working in our corner. Not only are they keeping tabs on the activists and what they are doing and saying, they are also sharing this valuable information with the animal agriculture industry. Members of the Alliance receive regular and more in-depth reports from activist events. I encourage organizations and individuals to support the alliance as much as they can so they can give farmers and ranchers the tools they need to fight back against the misinformation promoted by these groups.

And you can leave your cow suit at home.



Comments (6) Leave a comment 

Name
e-Mail (required)
Location

Comment:

characters left

Allen    
Illinois  |  November, 23, 2011 at 09:33 AM

It took such "courage" for your undercover operative to infiltrate a meeting that was billed as a discussion between animal advocates and the agriculture industry. What genius to discover a group with bumper stickers that read "Animals are friends, not food" thinks that people shouldn't eat animals. What incredible insight to sneak into a meeting that Tyson executives were invited to and learn that a group well known for its undercover investigations thinks that its investigations are important. This is crack reporting at its finest. Hats off to you. No wonder the ag sector is losing.

Terry Ward    
Pa.  |  November, 28, 2011 at 07:43 AM

Will all the middle-aged extremist ladies please raise their pink grenade launchers?

Joanna    
Vermont  |  November, 28, 2011 at 09:28 AM

Allen: With "Ending" in the title, does not sound like much of a discussion.

gotmilk    
pa  |  November, 28, 2011 at 10:27 AM

Allen, who was on the panel of conference speakers representing the agriculture industry for these "discussions"?

Maxine Jones    
Midland, SD  |  November, 29, 2011 at 07:45 AM

We know these fronts for animal rights, as opposed to animal welfare, are dedicated, but it isn't really to their 'princples of kindness to animals', but more obviously to their fundraising. The vast majority of money raised goes not to 'help' animals, but to salaries, benefits, and 'consulting fees' for their top level of staff and directors. With that motivation, plus the ability to 'investigate and litigate' against farmers who exercise their RIGHT to campaign in elections is a page taken from successful environmental extremists. It is looking very much like animal 'rights' groups are following the avenue of litigating their way to wealth which has been very successful for the groups and very cosly to both our federal government AND our farmers and ranchers.

supra shoes    
http://www.hisuprashoes.com  |  December, 14, 2011 at 10:11 PM

students is there anything special about their names. For example is it a family name


First Defense®

Currently the only USDA-approved colostrum derived product to defend against both K99+ E. coli and coronavirus, First Defense® can be ... Read More

View all Products in this segment

View All Buyers Guides

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight