Boxers or Briefs? Underwear buried to demonstrate unhealthy soil

 Resize text         Printer-friendly version of this article Printer-friendly version of this article

Men’s cotton briefs can serve the needs of science when buried in a field for a few weeks. It’s a takeoff on an agronomy soil test that uses cotton swatches to measure carbon consumption by microbes. Microbes living in soil with plenty of carbon, rich in organic matter to turn into energy, don’t have to eat the cotton. Bacteria in carbon-poor soil will eat what they can scavenge.

The “soiled underwear test” helped Clemson and North Carolina State University Extension specialists teaching a pasture ecology workshop make their points about the importance of healthy soil and how to build it from the grassroots down.

A cattle producer who understands how the interconnected web of life works can have healthier pastures that will be more resilient to drought and more productive over time.

“This is what happens when soil lacks carbon,” said Matt Poore, N.C. State animal scientist turned pasture ecologist.

Poore held up a pair of tidy-whiteys in tatters. Mostly it was the elastic waist and leg bands that remained. The demonstration showed the results of bacteria turning cotton into food. At the other end of the display, underwear that had been in carbon-rich soil were dirty but no worse for wear.

More than 15 cattle producers in the three-day course were impressed, though no one came forward for a closer look.

“There’s a lot going on underfoot that we can’t see but we need to know about and take care of,” said John Andrae, Clemson Extension forage specialist. “Many cattle producers grew up learning about the cow part of the operation and not so much about the rest of the system.”

Funded by a USDA grant, Andrae and Poore teamed up to teach cattle producers in the Southeast about the care and feeding of the interconnected communities live in the land. Managing pastures to support the soil foodweb involves a different way of thinking about the cattle producers’ task.

Cattle producers know that livestock and forage plants are the main parts of the system. The most important management decisions deal with controlling the animals so that they graze the top growth, minimizing long-term damage to the plant, according to Poore.

“Few of us, however, fully comprehend the complexity a managed ecosystem includes,” said Poore.

The cattle producers listened and took notes on topics ranging from the soil physical and its chemical properties to soil microorganisms, such as bacteria, protozoa and soil macro-organisms like earthworms, and nematodes of all kinds. There was also a lot to learn about insects, particularly dung beetles in manure; plant communities, including cool season and warm season grasses, legumes and weeds; and about cattle, wildlife and people, who are the managers.

“As managers it is important for us to come to an understanding of this system and how our management decisions influence all aspects of the system,” Poore wrote in a handout.

How a manager brings about change for the good – or the bad – includes a host of variables: fertilizer, pH levels, weed controls, altering the plant community by adding seed, deciding how long to let cattle graze, applying insecticides and dewormers that may affect insect communities.

“When you start thinking about all the components and how they work together, and then what we can do as managers to influence them, it can be overwhelming,” said Poore.

After three days of show and tell, the cattle producers had a headful of new ideas to ponder.

“We hope a few will use some of the practical recommendations we offered,” said Andrae. “Maybe they’ll fence off a section of pasture and rebuild it. If it works, we hope they’ll show other producers the results.”

It was a lot to take in, said Dixon Shealy of Newberry. His family runs Black Grove, raising Angus cattle.

“I came to learn how to make more powerful soil and pastures,” he said.

Prev 1 2 Next All

Comments (4) Leave a comment 

e-Mail (required)


characters left

Iowa  |  August, 22, 2014 at 12:45 PM

Amazing to think that carbon is food to the earth.

Tim Gieseke    
MN  |  August, 22, 2014 at 09:25 PM

And so we are starving our landscape...then I assume people fit somewhere along that path.

Houston Metro Area, TX  |  August, 28, 2014 at 05:54 AM

What happens if the soil is so "UNHEALTHY" (sterile or has low numbers of soil microbes)? Won't the cotton underwear ALSO be largely INTACT? (Implying the soil is CARBON-RICH? Which with few soil microbes - in a sense the soil WOULD BE CARBON-RICH as the soil microbes would NOT be ABLE to breakdown acccumulations of organic matter in the soil. The suggestion/implication is that COTTON fibers as a source of CELLULOSE organic matter are MUCH MORE difficult for soil microbes to breakdown than OTHER soil organic matter in "carbon-rich" soils? Other plant cellulosic organic matter is EASIER for soil microbes to breakdown (utilize for energy) than the DIFFICULT to breakdown cellulosic organic matter in COTTON fibers? This article hasn't satisfactorily explained (or convinced me) exactly what the COTTON UNDERWEAR TEST actually demonstrates.

earnest christ    
Oklahoma  |  September, 08, 2014 at 09:56 AM

The problem is that the carbon cycle is out of whack. Every time we till the soil or mis-manage our grasslands we are releasing more carbon dioxide than the soil is storing. Photosynthesis can put a lot of this back in the ground in the form of organic matter, but we have to manage for it. We have burned out the majority of our soils and we need to build them back if we are going to keep feeding everybody.

RANGER® Diesel, Sportsman® ATV Series

The Polaris Ranger Diesel sets new standards in terms of efficiency. With its efficient diesel engine, the vehicle is up ... Read More

View all Products in this segment

View All Buyers Guides

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight