Commentary: Meatless madness

 Resize text        

Most people involved with meat production are familiar with the Meatless Monday campaign, the brainchild of a pro-vegetarian group of health officials attached to the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. Initially launched about 10 years ago, the campaign was at first a thinly disguised bid to solicit “partners” (read, “contributors”) for the school, companies who loved the concept and just happened to be involved in manufacturing of a variety of commercially marketed vegetarian food products.

Since then, the campaign has ratcheted up, along with the rhetoric about meat production causing global warming and the horrors of factory farming and animal abuse.

Allegedly.

Now, another new partner has climbed aboard. Sodexo has announced that it is rolling out a Meatless Monday initiative,“in a bid to promote wellness and sustainability,”to more than 2,000 of its clients, following pilot programs at more than 900 U.S. hospitals, according to a company news release.

Sodexo, of course, is a multi-billion dollar foodservice operator that boasts that its mission is to “design, manage and deliver comprehensive service solutions through On-site Service Solutions and Motivation Solutions to create an outstanding experience for the people they serve.”

Talk about a mouthful of marketing-ese.

Among the clients Sodexo says it has recruited to join the meatless Mondays campaign are such organizations as:

  • Chicago-based Northern Trust Corporation(formerly Northern Trust Bank, but in the wake of the Wall Street meltdown and bailout, that last term has become a four-letter word), which styles itself as a “global leader in delivering innovative investment management, asset and fund administration, fiduciary and banking solutions to corporations, institutions and affluent individuals” and claims $4.4 trillion in “assets under custody,” whatever that means.
  • Toyota USA, which, despite the well-documented safety problems in its automobiles, you’ll be pleased to learn, is “Committed to Putting Our People, Customers & Community First.”
  • The federal Department of the Interior, which, you might be surprised to learn, has launched “the most aggressive oil and gas safety and reform agenda in U.S. history” and is “unlocking our nation’s renewable energy potential in unprecedented ways,”is also named as a supporter of Meatless Mondays—although a website search reveals only truly jingoistic story from 1943 about the “hard-working evacuees” at a Japanese-American internment camp in Idaho happily raising “healthy vegetables basking in the shimmery summer sun.”

I kid you not.

Uncovering the real reasons

Now, the question becomes this: Why is Sodexo so supportive of a campaign that is blatantly focusedon demonizing the meat industry and virtually transparent in its mission to convince consumers that red meat producers—and by extension, meat eaters—are the spawn of Satan himself?

There’s lots of happy talk in the company’s PR about supporting local produce growers (a good thing), capitalizing on the popularity of farmer’s markets (fine and dandy) and using the campaign as a vehicle for “promoting sustainability” (questionable but understandable as a marketing tool). And plenty of feel-good self-importance for a firm that doesn’t get a lot of media attention unless something has gone wrong.

“The response [to Meatless Mondays] has been very positive,” said Tracey Riddle, Sodexo's general manager at Toyota’s North American headquarters in Torrance, Calif. “The first week we ran it, we had people taking pictures of the sign.”

Sodexo’s Meatless Monday program highlights a vegetarian option from each of the various serving stations in the company’s cafeteria, Riddle explained. Meat dishes are still offered, but the vegetarian items receive “heavy promotion.”

“People just loved it,” Riddle claimed. “Our sales skyrocketed.”

Okay, now we’re getting close to the real reason Sodexo is so excited.

“To boot, the initiative has a small silver economic lining,” the firm’s news release stated. “It’s a lower product cost, so it does help the bottom line a little bit,” according to Riddle.

Case closed.

In the end, the proponents of Meatless Mondays are the same crowd pushing a plant-based diet as the solution to the planet’s various economic, nutritional and environmental woes. For example, here’s a sampling from a “Green Biz” website touring the campaign: “Why ditch meat for a day? Less animal protein means less of a risk of developing chronic conditions like heart disease, cancer, diabetes, and obesity. Risks to our environment will also be diminished as we trim meat from our plates by reducing our carbon footprint and cut fossil fuel demand.”

Apparently, about the only thing giving up meat doesn’t do is balance the federal budget and lower the price of gasoline.

But that’ll be next, trust me.

Of course, there’s nothing wrong with promoting nutritional variety, nothing untoward about supporting local food production and certainly nothing bad about encouraging Americans to eat healthier—on any day of the week.

So how about a “Fruitful Fridays” campaign instead? Wouldn’t that accomplish the same goals that the Meatless Monday people claim to be pursuing?

Only without all the anti-red meat rhetoric.

Dan Murphy is a veteran food-industry journalist and commentator


Prev 1 2 Next All


Sponsored Links


Comments (10) Leave a comment 

Name
e-Mail (required)
Location

Comment:

characters left

Bea Elliott    
florida  |  May, 06, 2011 at 11:19 AM

Fruitful Fridays? Or sour grapes?

Tony    
Vancouver  |  May, 06, 2011 at 04:26 PM

Sodexo used to manage our nasty school cafeteria lunches too. I'm staying away from their version of Meatless Monday.

Rebecca    
Michigan  |  May, 06, 2011 at 07:02 PM

“'People just loved it,' Riddle claimed. 'Our sales skyrocketed.' Okay, now we’re getting close to the real reason Sodexo is so excited."

People just don't like red meat. Your sales are down. Okay, now we're getting close to the real reason you are so angry.

fanya    
NYC  |  May, 06, 2011 at 08:27 PM

People need to find out what's in their "Meatless Mondays" meal. Hexane and GMOs anyone?

MELISSA    
BURLESON, TEXAS  |  May, 07, 2011 at 11:34 AM

MAYBE WE ALL SHOULD GO AND SEE "FORKS OVER KNIFES" AND THEN COME BACK AND HAVE THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT "HOW GOOD" MEAT IS FOR OUR BODIES, OR PERHAPS PICK UP A BOOK LIKE "EATING ANIMALS" AND READ ABOUT THE FINDINGS FROM THE OTHERSIDE BEFORE WE MOCK THE "MEATLESS FRIDAYS".

bill fielding    
waterloo ontario canada  |  May, 09, 2011 at 09:21 AM

Valid point Bea.
Dan does not discuss why Meatless Mondays are getting more and more support from people getting the choice.
All he does is whine.
Dan Murphy has written an absolutely pointless column.

Diana    
Idaho  |  May, 08, 2011 at 01:23 PM

The menu is not meat free, so no one is forced to choose the meatless alternative. The customers like an alternative to meat and the meatless option is cheaper for the company to produce. So what is your argument? Your gripe is that they aren't buying your product? You do not have the right to demand everyone purchase and serve your products. Sounds like Sodexo is using good old American business common sense to me.

Erin Gaines    
Texas  |  May, 09, 2011 at 09:42 AM

Nearly everyone I know is drastically cutting their meat and animal product consumption (and some are giving it up altogether)--for the animals, the planet, and their own health. It's just good business sense to offer vegetarian and vegan options!

Dirk    
Bloomington, IL  |  May, 10, 2011 at 10:50 AM

Sorry Dan, the public tide is turning against the horrific abuse heaped upon non-human animals in the name of industry and money.

P Diddy    
Tempe  |  July, 22, 2011 at 04:07 PM

Vegans are just trying to make the world suck less. And factory farming f*cking sucks. Trying to defend it is like trying to defend rape.


Feedback Form
Leads to Insight