Commentary: Dissing PETA

 Resize text        

Most fans of Jennifer Lawrence, the actress making serious waves in Hollywood for her star turn as Katniss Everdeen in the box-office blockbuster “The Hunger Games,” also know her as a former horror film “scream queen,” the alluring Raven Darkholme in “X Men: First Class” and for her scintillating and Oscar-nominated role in the movie “Winter’s Bone.”

That 2010 film, in which Lawrence portrayed “an Ozark Mountain girl who hacks through dangerous social terrain as she hunts down her drug-dealing father,” according to her bio, explored the socially volatile underworld of illegal methamphetamine labs and earned her accolades from critics and moviegoers alike.

Despite the dark roles she has taken on, most actors who have worked with her in various projects have described her as a fun down-to-earth person to be around. Her co-stars in The Hunger Games almost unanimously depict her as a bouncy, offbeat personality who is unafraid to say and do things about which most people—even celebrities—feel decidedly uncomfortable.

For example, according to a recent profile in Rolling Stone magazine, Lawrence told Hunger Games co-star Josh Hutcherson in her initial conversation with him about his role that he should, “Think about a catheter going in—ouch!” Hutcherson revealed that the discussion then “turned into a 45-minute rant about zombies and the apocalypse.”

In that article, Lawrence was asked about the infamous squirrel-skinning scene in Winter’s Bone. When asked if the scene was real or whether it was staged courtesy of some “movie magic,” the actress replied: “I should say it wasn’t real, for PETA—but screw PETA.”

Those last two words provoked a blistering rebuttal from the ethical folks involved with the animal rights extremists.

Like Lawrence, they’re very skilled at feigning shock and horror—only she’s performing in a movie role; PETA does it for a living.

Another sample of practiced outrage

PETA released a statement attributed to President Ingrid Newkirk that said, “She’s young and the plight of animals somehow hasn’t yet touched her heart. As Henry David Thoreau said, ‘The squirrel you kill in jest, dies in earnest.’ When people kill animals, it is the animals who are ‘screwed,’ not PETA. One day, I hope she will try to make up for any pain she might cause any animal who did nothing but try to eke out a humble existence in nature.”

According to Hollywood gossip mavens E! News, it was reported that despite it seeming like skinning a squirrel didn’t bother Lawrence, in an earlier 2010 interview, she confessed to getting emotional when learning how to do it for real when her brother's friend demonstrated the process.

“He cut it open,” she recalled. “And then I went and cried in the house and let him finish.”

Newkirk predicted that in the future, Lawrence would develop “a more positive relationship with animals.”

“[Lawrence’s comment] was just a throw-away remark,” according to her statement. “We have our bet on Jennifer ending up joining the ranks of other young celebrities like Natalie Portman, Lea Michele and Kellan Lutz, who are using their influence to help animals.”

Those sentiments may not be shared quite so smugly by Lawrence’s legion of fans. In fact, several posted comments on MTV’s website, and one self-declared animal-rights supporter wrote, “I love animals, and I like that there are organizations that help animals.” The post went on to use expletives to criticize PETA for “dissing on the most awesomest actress ever!”

I might have chosen slightly different phrasing, but I couldn’t have stated it any more succinctly.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Dan Murphy, a veteran food-industry journalist and commentator.


Prev 1 2 Next All


Sponsored Links


Comments (0) Leave a comment 

Name
e-Mail (required)
Location

Comment:

characters left


Feedback Form
Leads to Insight